diff --git a/plugin-designs/my-upg-100-list/data/adm0/PROVENANCE.json b/plugin-designs/my-upg-100-list/data/adm0/PROVENANCE.json index 7a273f255..bff75663b 100644 --- a/plugin-designs/my-upg-100-list/data/adm0/PROVENANCE.json +++ b/plugin-designs/my-upg-100-list/data/adm0/PROVENANCE.json @@ -5,8 +5,197 @@ "endpoint": "https://www.geoboundaries.org/api/current/gbOpen///", "note": "gbOpen passes through each country UPSTREAM licence — this collection is MIXED-LICENCE with per-country attribution duties.", "adm0_features": 162, - "_duty": "130 of the 162 countries carry an ATTRIBUTION or SHARE-ALIKE duty that travels with any redistribution of boundaries/world-adm0*.geojson. Only 32 are duty-free (Public Domain or CC0). This matters because the repo is intended to be given away: CC BY obligations are not discharged by shipping the file, they are discharged by naming the source. See data/boundaries/ATTRIBUTION.", - "_shareAlike": "These 7 are ShareAlike, a STRONGER duty than attribution — a derivative may have to be licensed alike. Flagged separately because a blanket 'CC BY' summary would hide them: AGO, GAB, GEO, GIN, MMR, NER, TUR", + "_duty": "130 of the 162 countries carry a duty that travels with any redistribution of boundaries/world-adm0*.geojson; only 32 are duty-free. The 130 split TWO ways and the split matters more than the total: 65 are attribution-only, and 65 are SHARE-ALIKE CLASS (58 ODbL + 7 explicit ShareAlike), which can constrain how a derivative is licensed rather than merely how it is credited. See _duty_classes. This matters because the repo is intended to be given away: these obligations are not discharged by shipping the file. See data/boundaries/ATTRIBUTION, which references this table by path.", + "_duty_classes": { + "_why": "THREE CLASSES, NOT TWO — corrected 2026-09-28 after regions-plugin's challenge, which was right. I first gave only the 7 explicitly-named ShareAlike countries their own field on the reasoning that share-alike is a stronger duty than attribution. By that same reasoning the field should hold 65: Open Data Commons ODbL 1.0 is itself a SHARE-ALIKE licence for databases — alongside attribution it requires a Derivative Database be offered under ODbL, and it has a keep-open provision. Separating 7 from 58 buried exactly the thing the field existed to surface.", + "_precedent": "THIS REPO ALREADY TREATS ODbL AS CONSEQUENTIAL, which is the evidence rather than my reading of the licence: library/scripts/posters/data/README.md:36-50 records that Natural Earth's 1:10m ROADS were requested and DELIBERATELY NOT SHIPPED because of an ODbL attribution obligation. Someone here dropped a dataset over this class of duty.", + "_open": "NOT A LEGAL CONCLUSION. Whether a redistributed boundary file is a 'Derivative Database' under ODbL is exactly the clause a giveaway needs a real answer on, and neither regions-plugin nor I is qualified to give it. Recorded here, and raised with the licensing items, so the question is visible rather than settled by omission.", + "duty_free": { + "count": 32, + "iso3": [ + "AFG", + "ALB", + "AND", + "ARE", + "ATG", + "BEN", + "BGD", + "BGR", + "BHS", + "BIH", + "BOL", + "BRN", + "CHN", + "CIV", + "COL", + "DJI", + "ECU", + "GHA", + "IND", + "IRN", + "IRQ", + "JAM", + "KEN", + "LBN", + "LBY", + "LCA", + "MLT", + "PAN", + "PER", + "SLB", + "USA", + "VEN" + ] + }, + "attribution_only": { + "count": 65, + "iso3": [ + "ABW", + "ARM", + "ASM", + "AZE", + "BFA", + "BLM", + "BLR", + "BMU", + "BRA", + "BRB", + "BTN", + "CAF", + "CMR", + "COK", + "CUW", + "CYM", + "CZE", + "DMA", + "ESP", + "FRO", + "FSM", + "GGY", + "GLP", + "GMB", + "GRC", + "GUF", + "GUM", + "GUY", + "ISL", + "JOR", + "JPN", + "LBR", + "MDV", + "MLI", + "MNP", + "MRT", + "MSR", + "MYT", + "NAM", + "NCL", + "NGA", + "NIU", + "NPL", + "NZL", + "PHL", + "PRK", + "PRY", + "PSE", + "PYF", + "SDN", + "SEN", + "SHN", + "SLE", + "SOM", + "SSD", + "SWE", + "TCA", + "TZA", + "VGB", + "VIR", + "VNM", + "WLF", + "ZAF", + "ZMB", + "ZWE" + ] + }, + "share_alike_class": { + "count": 65, + "odbl_1_0": { + "count": 58, + "iso3": [ + "BHR", + "COD", + "COG", + "COM", + "CUB", + "CYP", + "DZA", + "EGY", + "ERI", + "ETH", + "FIN", + "FJI", + "GNB", + "GNQ", + "GRD", + "IDN", + "ISR", + "KAZ", + "KGZ", + "KHM", + "KIR", + "KWT", + "LAO", + "LIE", + "LKA", + "LUX", + "MAR", + "MHL", + "MNE", + "MNG", + "MOZ", + "MUS", + "MWI", + "MYS", + "OMN", + "PAK", + "PLW", + "PNG", + "QAT", + "RUS", + "SAU", + "SMR", + "STP", + "SUR", + "SWZ", + "SYR", + "TCD", + "TGO", + "THA", + "TJK", + "TON", + "TUN", + "UGA", + "UZB", + "VCT", + "VUT", + "WSM", + "YEM" + ] + }, + "explicit_sharealike": { + "count": 7, + "iso3": [ + "AGO", + "GAB", + "GEO", + "GIN", + "MMR", + "NER", + "TUR" + ] + } + } + }, "summary": { "countries": 162, "duty_free": 32,